Marathon · Key Colony Beach · Islamorada

Local Restaurants

From dockside fish shacks to waterfront dining, the Florida Keys has some of the best seafood and local flavor in the country. Here are our favorites near the retreat.

Keys Fisheries

$$

A Marathon institution. Order the lobster Reuben at the outdoor counter, grab a cold one, and eat on the docks while the pelicans beg for scraps. Doesn't get more Keys than this.

3502 Gulfview Ave, Marathon, FL5 min driveMust try: Lobster Reuben

Burdines Waterfront

$$

Casual waterfront spot right on the marina. Fresh fish sandwiches, cold beer, and a laid-back Keys vibe. Great for lunch after a morning on the water.

1200 Oceanview Ave, Marathon, FL5 min driveMust try: Fish sandwich

Castaway Waterfront Restaurant

$$$

Waterfront dining with fresh local catch and great sunset views over the Gulf. A solid choice for a nicer dinner out without leaving Marathon.

1406 Oceanview Ave, Marathon, FL6 min driveMust try: Catch of the day

Porky's Bayside BBQ

$$

BBQ and seafood right on the bay. Laid-back atmosphere, big portions, and a great spot to watch the sunset with a cold drink in hand.

1410 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL7 min driveMust try: BBQ ribs or smoked fish dip

Cabana Club Restaurant & Bar

$$

Right on the property — exclusive to Cabana Club members and guests. Cold drinks, casual bites, and the best pool-and-beach combo in Key Colony Beach. Included with your stay.

Key Colony Beach Cabana Club, Marathon, FLWalking distanceMust try: Frozen drinks by the pool

The Stuffed Pig

$

The best breakfast spot in Marathon. Cash only, no-frills diner with massive portions and a line out the door on weekends. Worth every minute of the wait.

3520 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL8 min driveMust try: Breakfast platter

Sparky's Landing

$$

Waterfront tiki bar and grill with live music on weekends. Cold beer, fresh fish tacos, and a great sunset view. A local favorite for happy hour.

1 Sombrero Blvd, Marathon, FL6 min driveMust try: Fish tacos

Lazy Days Restaurant

$$$

Oceanfront dining in Islamorada with stunning views and fresh Keys seafood. A bit of a drive but absolutely worth it for a special night out.

79867 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL35 min driveMust try: Yellowtail snapper

Ready to explore?

Book your stay at Reel Axed Retreat and use this as your personal dining guide for the trip.

Book Your Stay
Reelaxed Rentals

Your home away from home on the coast. Kick off your shoes, feel the sand, and let the ocean do the rest.

Our Properties

Get in Touch

© 2026 Reelaxed Rentals. All rights reserved.

Life's better at the beach.